Pursuing Botanical Sports Supplements Means Separating Fact from Fiction

Elan Sudberg, CEO

May 23, 2013

3 Min Read
Pursuing Botanical Sports Supplements Means Separating Fact from Fiction

As the CEO of a quickly growing testing lab, I offset the stresses of work and life with a strict regimen of boot-camp-like exercise. That said, I am also guilty of trying to alleviate my self-induced fitness hardships and enhance my physical abilities with a barrage of novel sports supplements, specifically powdered pre-workout sports nutrition supplements and post-workout supplements.  

During a vigorous workout, it is not uncommon for muscles to experience a small amount of damage. That produces the sore feeling some of us either seek as a prideful/macho sign of progress or use as an excuse to avoid working out in the first place. It is possible to offset this soreness by consuming protein (a glass of milk or a protein bar) afterward. However, a new family has moved to the block called pre-workout boosters (PWBs) and post-workout drinks (PWDs) that are changing the landscape for the fitness enthusiast on a global scale.

The evolution of this product category has been cyclical over the years all the while claiming to produce energy, increase hydration, and promote muscle recovery. Botanical ingredients have been a part of this evolution in some way the entire time.

In the beginning, the PWBs and PWDs were dominated by performance-boosting ingredients like caffeine, beta-alanine, nitrous oxide, creatine, and a little (or in some cases, a lot) of ephedra. When ephedra became a four-letter word, the search began for safer alternatives. Formulators decided to include some botanicals, like green tea or guarana, in what seemed to be an effort to naturalize the product and to even neutralize the potential negative connotation of the synthetic ingredients.

Now it seems that those botanicals have been rendered down to botanically derived ingredients like caffeine from green tea and/ or guarana. Dont be tricked by these ingredients: many of them are custom plant extracts heavily focused on the caffeine fraction. These ingredients may not be green tea or guarana, rather, caffeine possibly from green tea, or guarana, or some combinationthere is no easy way to confirm the caffeines origin without the proper testing.

Lately, its hard not to read about this genre without coming across the new troublemaker on the block, methylhexaneamine (MHA)/dimethylamylamine (DMAA), mixed with our old friend caffeine. These are being offered in dangerous levels. In some cases, these products are fortified with such ingredients without the end users awareness (or consent), potentially causing serious health risks. While they are sought after for their thermogenic or stimulant effects, the FDA isnt shy to quickly call out and remove products found to contain such ingredients.

In the background, there is a new movement of clean PWBs and PWDs flying the vegan flag of health. While these appear to be on the right side of the track, they still push a lot of the usual suspects: caffeine-containing botanicals and/or an array of amino acids and salts. All these choices, coupled with the changing landscape of sports supplements, make me ask myself this question: If I need to be fortifying my nutrition with supplements (that may or may not be deemed healthy in a years time) in order to perform at a high level, is it possible I shouldnt be attempting to perform at a high level? Is this natural?

A sports nutrition product manufacturer should be able to answer this question by showing the safety of its product, backed by scientific research, third-party certifications, and lab testing

Regardless of the trends, I still believe in the age-old saying of caveat emptor: Buyer Beware. Manufacturers, consumerseveryone actuallyneed to read those labels and understand them.

About the Author(s)

Elan Sudberg

CEO, Alkemist Labs

Élan M. Sudberg is CEO of Alkemist Labs, a passionately committed contract testing laboratory specializing in plant and fungal identity, potency and purity testing for the food, beverage, nutraceutical and psychedelic industries. His favorite part of his job is catching cheaters, and he is known for pushing the industry to continually raise the bar on quality and transparency. Élan holds a degree in chemistry from California State University Long Beach, and he is on the American Herbal Products Association (AHPA) board of trustees.

Subscribe and receive the latest insights on the health and nutrition industry.
Join 37,000+ members. Yes, it's completely free.

You May Also Like